So after talking with several people I decided to stay with 33"s until the Jeep is no longer my daily driver.

That said it is time to buy some new tires.

I have ran Cooper STT's for the past two years and they are near 50k now. They have worn unevenly, but have performed well in every environment I've been to. (although the only "off-road tire I have to compare is the BFG AT's)

That said I am considering switching to the BFG KM2s or the Goodyear MT/Rs.
They are all close enough in price for that to not be an issue.

Thoughts, experiences, and opinions are greatly appreciated.